I'm Andy Temte and welcome to Money Lessons! Join me every Saturday morning for bite-sized lessons that are designed to improve financial literacy around the world. Today is November 14, 2026.
Last Saturday I promised that today we'd take up pay that isn't salary — bonuses, commissions, and tips. Let's say your employer tells you that you've earned a $10,000 bonus, the check arrives, and the amount deposited is closer to $7,000 than to $10,000. Many people conclude from that check that the government taxes a bonus at a higher rate than a paycheck. That conclusion is wrong, and to see why, we'll follow that $10,000 bonus from the check to the tax return. Then we'll finish with what the law says about tips, including a new deduction for tips.
Three Forms of Pay
Bonuses come in several forms: a signing bonus, paid for taking the job; an annual bonus, paid when the business, or you, hit a target for the year; and the retention bonus we named on October 17th — a bonus paid to keep you from leaving, which you keep only if you stay through a certain date.
Commissions are paid as a share of what you sell — a percentage of each sale, or of the sales you close in a month — and some commission jobs come with a draw. A draw against commission is an advance: the employer pays you a set amount each pay period, the commissions you earn pay that advance back first, and you keep whatever commission is left after the advance is repaid. A draw keeps a paycheck coming in a slow month; it is not extra pay. When is a commission yours? When the commission plan your employer wrote says it has been earned — at the sale, or when the business receives the cash from the sale — so read that plan before you count on the money. A plan that pays on the sale can come with a clawback: a provision that takes the commission back if the cash from the sale is never collected in full.
A tip is money a customer chooses to give you for service, and the customer sets the amount. That is what separates a tip from a mandatory service charge printed on the bill: the business set that amount, and the business decides whether any of it is paid to you.
So what unites the three? Under federal tax law, a bonus, a commission, and a tip are all wages, the same as your salary or your hourly pay. They're reported on your W-2, the form your employer sends you every January reporting your pay and the taxes withheld. Social Security tax, Medicare tax, and federal income tax are owed on all three. Said differently, the tax law doesn't care whether a payment is called a bonus, a commission, or a tip: if your employer paid you for your work, the payment is wages. None of the three has a tax rate of its own, and that is where the misconception about bonuses comes from.
The 22 Percent
The IRS has a name for pay that isn't your regular wages: supplemental wages. Bonuses, commissions, overtime pay, severance pay, and tips are all supplemental wages. For your regular wages, your employer estimates your income tax every payday from your pay and your Form W-4, the way we walked through on September 19th. For supplemental wages, the IRS gives your employer a simpler method. When a bonus or a commission is paid on a separate check, or on a separate line of a regular check, the employer is allowed to withhold a flat 22 percent of it for federal income tax, without using the withholding tables or your W-4. Social Security and Medicare tax, together 7.65 percent, come out on top of that, and so does your state's income tax withholding, if your state has one.
Let's follow the $10,000 bonus. Suppose you're single, your salary is $90,000 a year, and your employer pays the bonus on a separate check and uses the flat rate. Federal income tax withholding at 22 percent is $2,200. Social Security and Medicare tax together, at 7.65 percent, come to $765. Add the two together and $2,965 has come out before any state tax, which is just under 30 percent of the bonus. Add your state's withholding, and it can look like more than a third of your bonus is gone. So it's easy to conclude that bonuses are taxed at a higher rate. They aren't.
Here's why. Back on September 19th we said that federal income tax withholding is a prepayment of your income tax, and that your marginal tax rate is the rate on the last dollar you earn. The tax itself is calculated once, on your tax return, where the bonus is added to the rest of your income and taxed bracket by bracket, the same as every other dollar you earned. For our single filer with a $90,000 salary, the standard deduction of $16,100 — and, to keep it simple, no pre-tax deductions — brings taxable income to $73,900. That falls in the 22 percent bracket, the one that runs from $50,400 to $105,700, and a $10,000 bonus added to it fits inside the same bracket. So the income tax on the bonus is 22 percent of $10,000, which is $2,200, exactly what was withheld. Nothing more is owed in April, and nothing comes back. Note what that means: the bonus was taxed at the same rate as the last dollar of salary, not a higher one.
Note that the flat 22 percent and your bracket won't always match. If your salary puts your last dollar in the 12 percent bracket, the 22 percent withholds more than the tax on the bonus, and the extra comes back to you in your refund. If your last dollar is in the 24 percent bracket, the 22 percent withholds a little less than the tax on the bonus, and you pay the difference when you file.
Tips: The Tip Credit and a New Deduction
Tips come with wage rules of their own, written into the Fair Labor Standards Act — the federal law we named last Saturday that sets the minimum wage and the overtime rule. The federal minimum wage is $7.25 an hour. For a tipped employee — someone who customarily receives more than $30 a month in tips — the law lets the employer pay a cash wage of as little as $2.13 an hour and count the tips toward the rest of your minimum wage. That arrangement is called the tip credit. The employer has to tell you it's using the tip credit, and if your tips plus the $2.13 don't add up to $7.25 an hour for the week, the employer must pay you the difference. That $2.13 cash wage was set in 1991, and a 1996 law froze it there; the minimum wage has risen since, and the $2.13 hasn't. Note that $2.13 is the federal floor, and most states set a higher one. Wisconsin, where I live, sets its tipped cash wage at $2.33, and seven states — Alaska, California, Minnesota, Montana, Nevada, Oregon, and Washington — allow no tip credit at all, so a tipped worker there is paid the state's full minimum wage before tips. Whenever a state's law on wages and tips is better for the worker than the federal law, the state's law is the one that applies.
Two more things the law says about tips. First, the tips are yours. Federal law says your employer, your manager, and your supervisor cannot keep any part of your tips, for any reason; the one arrangement the law allows is a tip pool, which shares tips among the staff, never with managers or supervisors. Second, tips are reported. When your tips come to $20 or more in a month, you report them to your employer, and your employer withholds Social Security tax, Medicare tax, and income tax on them from your paycheck, the same as on your hourly pay.
Fun fact, the tax law signed on July 4, 2025 — the one that made the "half" in time-and-a-half deductible, which we covered last Saturday — did the same for tips. For tax years 2025 through 2028, you can deduct up to $25,000 a year of reported tips from the income your federal income tax is figured on. The deduction shrinks for incomes above $150,000, or $300,000 if you're married filing jointly. You don't have to itemize to take it, and it's claimed on a new form, Schedule 1-A, that goes with your tax return. There are three limits to this deduction. The job has to be one that customarily received tips before the end of 2024 — a server, a bartender, a barber or hairstylist, a delivery driver — and the IRS publishes the list. The tips have to have been reported, on your W-2 or on Form 4137 if you report tips yourself, so an unreported tip earns no deduction. And it is a deduction from federal income tax only: Social Security and Medicare tax still come out of every tip, just as they do from every overtime dollar, and whether your state's income tax follows the deduction is your state's decision — as of this recording, about half of the states with an income tax have adopted the deduction, and about half have not.
What This Means for You
If any part of your pay is a bonus, a commission, or tips, the lesson today is that all of it is wages. The tax on it is figured on your annual tax return, at your marginal rate, and the withholding you see on a bonus check is a prepayment at a flat rate, not the actual tax that's due. So the next time a bonus check looks small, you'll know where the money went, and you'll know that if the prepayment was more than the tax, the difference comes back when you file, and if it was less, you pay the difference then.
So here's your homework this week. Find the last pay stub that carried a bonus or a commission, and compare the federal income tax withheld with the amount of the bonus or commission. If the pay came on a separate check, or on a separate line, and the withholding is 22 percent of it, your employer used the flat rate. Then, if a bonus is coming before the end of the year, run the IRS Tax Withholding Estimator, the free tool we talked about on September 19th. It will tell you whether the bonus leaves your withholding for the year ahead or behind, and what to put on a new W-4 if you want to close the gap. I've put the link to the IRS Tax Withholding Estimator at the bottom of today's post.
Next Saturday we take up the gig economy: earning through an app with your own car, and the costs you'll bear that the app doesn't show you.
Until next week... Grace. Dignity. Compassion.
IRS Tax Withholding Estimator: https://www.irs.gov/individuals/tax-withholding-estimator